Sun - Thurs: 11am - 9:30pm
Fri: 11am - 10pm
Sat: 8am - 10pm
Sun - Thurs: 11am - 9:30pm
Fri: 11am - 10pm
Sat: 8am - 10pm

America’s Favorite Ice Cream Flavors

Posted by Jake Best on March 3, 2023

There is perhaps no debate more common than what flavor of ice cream is the best. While all taste is subjective, the analogy of “chocolate and vanilla” has been used many times when comparing two opposing topics. Today, we consult the hungry masses to discover what the favorite flavors are among the people. 

sarasota ice cream


This might not come as a surprise to anyone, but Vanilla is the favorite flavor of America. It’s tasty and pairs well with a variety of foods. After all, it’s the cornerstone of the wonderful dish known as a hot fudge sundae. 


It’s only natural that chocolate comes close to timing with vanilla as America’s favorite cold delight. While chocolate doesn’t pair with the variety of dishes that vanilla does, chocolate is known for its versatility and variety of flavors. Besides, who doesn’t enjoy the award-winning combination of chocolate and peanut butter? 

Cookies & Cream 

Here’s a delightful combination for those of you who have a sweet tooth. Cookies and cream are one of the most popular flavors, as it takes the foundation of vanilla and builds upon it with crunchy cookies. The most common of these is none other than Oreos, but some have attested to the potency of peanut butter cups. 

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 

Another popular choice that utilizes vanilla as its foundation, this one is a favorite of many. You might have fond memories of being a child and delighting in the taste of raw cookie dough while your mother was in the process of baking up some sweets. With chunks of raw dough paired with vanilla, this is a taste that will take you back every time. 


It’s no surprise that Neapolitan ice cream is as popular as it is. For those of us who have trouble deciding on just one flavor to enjoy, With chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla all in one, you can focus your attention on other pressing matters. 

Buttered Pecan 

A regional favorite in the southern United States, buttered pecan pairs the sweet and crunchy together for a truly decadent taste. The saltiness of the pecans greatly accentuates the flavor of the ice cream and pairs exceptionally well with gummy worms. 

Jake’s Ice Cream on Siesta Key 

No matter what time of year it is or what flavor you enjoy most, there’s never a bad time to dig into some tasty ice cream. At Jake’s Ice Cream on Siesta Key, we offer the best flavors that are unbelievable in their tastiness. For a menu and directions, hop on over to

Leave us a Review on Facebook, Google, and Yelp!

© 2022 Jake’s Ice Cream on Siesta Key - All Rights Reserved | Website by DigiSphere Marketing